Azara Blog: Children who spend more time in nursery are allegedly more anti-social

Blog home page | Blog archive

Google   Bookmark and Share

Date published: 2007/04/05

The BBC says:

Toddlers who spend three or more days a week in nursery are more likely to become anti-social, worried and upset, government research has found.

The evaluation of a £370m scheme to expand children's centres found youngsters were more likely to behave poorly the longer they spent in care.

But the report also found 30 hours in care increased children's confidence.

The research comes as teachers warn children are being "institutionalised" by the push to get mothers into work.

The study - A National Evaluation of Neighbourhood Nurseries - assessed the neighbourhood nurseries initiative, which was set up in 2001 to provide more childcare in some of the poorest parts of the country.

The report, carried out by academics at Oxford for the Department for Education and Skills, said: "The 'tipping point' for daily attendance appears to be relatively low in relation to anti-social behaviour.

"When compared with children who attended either one or two days per week, children who attended for three days per week or more were significantly more anti-social."

The number of months in day-care also affected behaviour.

"For the group as a whole, the number of months children had been attending their neighbourhood nursery also had an impact," the study said.

"The longer they had been attending their neighbourhood nursery, the more anti-social they were.

"Further analysis suggested that, when compared with children who had been attending their neighbourhood nursery for less than a year, children who had been attending for 18 months or more were rated as significantly more anti-social."

The study also found young children showed more "worried and upset behaviours" when they attended a mixed-age room with children aged four and over.

"In mixed groups, they were more likely to frown, shrug, pout or stamp their feet when given an idea for playing or to be worried about not getting enough attention, or access to toys, food or drink.

"Thus, mixed-aged groups may be better for children in terms of cognitive outcomes, but not in terms of behavioural outcomes."

However, the research found the more time children spent each week in day-care, the more confident they were and the more sociable with their peers.

It also found parents using neighbourhood nurseries were highly satisfied with the quality of care provided.

It's only one study so the result has to be taken with a pinch of salt. Indeed, the parents are supposedly satisified, and the children are allegedly "more sociable with their peers", but the children are allegedly "more anti-social". It makes you wonder how they determined that someone is "anti-social" and whether the difference between the various groups was really significant or just amplified to make the study seem more significant than it was. And were there any other significant factors (e.g. household income) that was correlated with how much time the children spent in day-care?

All material not included from other sources is copyright For further information or questions email: info [at] cambridge2000 [dot] com (replace "[at]" with "@" and "[dot]" with ".").