Azara Blog: Exposure to pesticides is linked with brain tumours

Blog home page | Blog archive

Google   Bookmark and Share

Date published: 2007/06/05

The BBC says:

Agricultural workers exposed to high levels of pesticides have a raised risk of brain tumours, research suggests.

The French study also indicated a possible higher risk among people who used pesticides on houseplants.

All agricultural workers exposed to pesticides had a slightly elevated brain tumour risk, it suggested.

But the Occupational and Environmental Medicine study found the risk was more than doubled for those exposed to the highest levels.

The risk of a type of central nervous system tumour known as a glioma was particularly heightened among this group - more than three times the risk in the general population.

Gliomas are more common in men than women, and the researchers speculate that part of the reason might be that men are more often exposed to pesticides.

However, the overall risk of developing a brain tumour remained very low.

UK experts said the findings were inconclusive.

The findings were based on an analysis of 221 cases of brain tumours by the French Institute of Public Health, Epidemiology and Development.

The research took place in the Bordeaux wine-growing region, where 80% of all pesticides used are fungicides.

The chemicals are mixed and sprayed in a mist to protect vines from fungal attack.

However, the researchers were unable to get specific enough data to pin down exactly which types of pesticide were associated with the development of brain tumours.

They also found that the use of pesticides indoors for house plants seemed to be associated with a more than two-fold increase in the risk of brain tumour.

But they admitted further work would be needed to confirm this association - again because of a lack of detail about which pesticides were used in enclosed home environments.

Josephine Querido, science information officer at Cancer Research UK, said: "More research is needed to confirm the observations made in this study as the results were based on people's recollection of pesticide exposure.

"Brain tumours are relatively rare and, although workers exposed to high levels of pesticides in industry or farming may be at higher risk of certain cancers, current evidence is inconclusive and any risks are likely to be very small."

Kathy Oliver, secretary of the International Brain Tumour Alliance, said: "Our organisation maintains contact with the world's leading specialists in brain tumours and unfortunately no single cause has yet been identified.

"The French study has identified an area warranting further investigation, however, we caution that the results should not be exaggerated.

"It is important to emphasise that more research is required before people start throwing out their cans of household pesticides."

A spokesman for the Crop Protection Association said: "Pesticides are some of the most thoroughly regulated chemicals in the world.

"There is no conclusive scientific evidence of a link between pesticides and brain tumours.

"This type of study does not demonstrate cause and effect, and the authors themselves admit that they did not identify which pesticides were used or the levels of exposure."

As with most health studies, they just show a correlation not a causation. And correlations prove very little, even if they provide juicy headlines for the media. Of course they can get away with just showing correlations because pretty much everyone believes that pesticides are bad. And even if the risk is doubled, double a very small number is still a very small number, and another problem with these articles is that they manage to dwell on the multiplier without looking at the underlying rate. Not to mention that it is only one study with a fairly small sample.

All material not included from other sources is copyright For further information or questions email: info [at] cambridge2000 [dot] com (replace "[at]" with "@" and "[dot]" with ".").