Tiffany Census

St. Thomas Episcopal Church, New Windsor, New York

Note: the text in the square brackets ([...]) are a short form of references which have been used to deduce the corresponding information.
The meaning of the site and item attributes is explained in the glossary.

Site Id:	3.81.1
Rating:	1 star
Address:	37 Old Route 9W
Location:	New Windsor, New York 12553, USA
Lat/Lng:	41.47078, -74.01726
Tiffany 1910:	Page 29
Duncan 1980:	Page 206
Tiffany 1897:	Page 20
Tiffany 1893:	Not listed
Tiffany 1886:	Not listed
Completeness:	Medium
Building status:	Extant
Building date:	1847-1848 [ORG]
Architect:	Owen G. Warren [ORG]
Comment:	The building was for sale in Apr 2026 [RAND2026]
Also of interest:	Coe Memorial Window, "Hope", by Maitland Armstrong [ORG]
	Coe Memorial Window, ornamental with cross, by Maitland Armstrong [ORG]
See also:	David and Helen Maitland Armstrong Census

Site Items

3.81.1.1:	ornamental windows (Unknown)
3.81.1.2:	Nicoll Memorial Window: Calvary (Removed)
3.81.1.3:	Archangel Gabriel (1887) (Extant)
3.81.1.4:	Chrystie Memorial Window: ornamental with cross and angel faces (1887) (Extant)

Item 3.81.1.1

Glossary (of terms) and References (as found in square brackets [...])

Status:	Unknown
Confidence:	Medium
Memorial name:
Description:	ornamental windows [TIFF1897, TIFF1910, DUNC1980]
Tiffany 1910:	Page 29
Duncan 1980:	Page 206
Tiffany 1897:	Page 20
Signature:
Other documentation:
Designer:
Memorial details:
Donor:
Date:
Inscription:
Category:	Ornamental
Same as item:	Possibly includes 3.81.1.4 and the outer two panes of 3.81.1.3

Item 3.81.1.2

You can click on the photo to get the full sized image.

Glossary (of terms) and References (as found in square brackets [...])

Status:	Removed [PHOTO, AW2026, EB2026]
Confidence:	High
Memorial name:	Nicoll Memorial Window
Theme:	Calvary [TIFF1910, DUNC1980]
Tiffany 1910:	Page 29
Duncan 1980:	Page 206
Tiffany 1897:	Not listed
Signature:	TIFFANY STVDIOS / NEW YORK [PHOTO]

Other documentation:
Designer:
Memorial details:	Leonard Francis Nicoll M.D. (3 Nov 1876 - 25 Nov 1906) [INSCRIPTION, ORG]
Donor:
Date:
Lancets:	1 [PHOTO]
Inscription:	There is a green hill far away, Without a city wall. / Where our dear Lord was crucified, Who died to save us all. / IN MEMORIAM / LEONARD FRANCIS NICOLL M.D. / BORN NOV. 3RD 1876 + DIED NOV. 25TH 1906 [PHOTO]
Category:	Calvary; Landscape
History:	Window removed ca. 2026 [AW2026, EB2026, DEDUCED]
Tiffany/Duncan comment:	Tiffany 1910 spells the name as Nichol [TIFF1910, DUNC1980]

Item 3.81.1.3

You can click on the photo to get the full sized image.

Glossary (of terms) and References (as found in square brackets [...])

Status:	Extant [PHOTO]
Confidence:	High
Memorial name:
Theme:	Archangel Gabriel [DMA1999, ORG]
Tiffany 1910:	Not listed
Duncan 1980:	Not listed
Tiffany 1897:	Not listed
Signature:
Other documentation:	[CHU1887]
Designer:	David Maitland Armstrong [DMA1999, ORG]
Memorial details:
Donor:	the two side panels, at least, were donated by Stephen Brewer Musgrave [ORG, FINDAGRAVE]
Date:	Installed ca. Apr 1887 [CHU1887]
Lancets:	3 [PHOTO]
Inscription:	S B M // NOVEMBER 11 AD 1884 // I AM THE RESURRECTION / AND THE LIFE SAITH / THE LORD // WHOSOEVER LIVETH / AND BELIEVETH IN ME / SHALL NEVER DIE [PHOTO]
Category:	Gabriel
Location:	chancel [PHOTO, DMA1999, CHU1887]
Cost:	$150 for the two side panels [ORG]
Comment:	This is really a Maitland Armstrong window but the Tiffany Glass Company executed it [DMA1999, CHU1887]
Same as item:	Possibly the outer two panes are part of 3.81.1.1

Item 3.81.1.4

You can click on the photo to get the full sized image.

Chrystie Memorial Window: ornamental with cross and angel faces

Glossary (of terms) and References (as found in square brackets [...])

Status:	Extant [PHOTO]
Confidence:	High
Memorial name:	Chrystie Memorial Window
Description:	ornamental with cross and angel faces [PHOTO]
Tiffany 1910:	Not listed
Duncan 1980:	Not listed
Tiffany 1897:	Not listed
Signature:
Other documentation:	[CHU1887, DEDUCED]
Designer:	David Maitland Armstrong [ORG]
Memorial details:	Frances Nicholson Chrystie (11 Dec 1850 - 26 Dec 1875) [INSCRIPTION]
Donor:
Date:	Installed ca. Apr 1887 [CHU1887]
Lancets:	1 [PHOTO]
Inscription:	THEIR ANGELS DO ALWAYS / BEHOLD THE FACE OF MY / FATHER WHICH IS IN HEAVEN // FRANCES NICHOLSON CHRYSTIE / BORN 11 DECEMBER AD 1850 / DIED 26 DECEMBER AD 1875 [PHOTO]
Category:	Ornamental
Comment:	This is really a Maitland Armstrong window but the Tiffany Glass Company executed it [CHU1887, DEDUCED]
Same as item:	Possibly part of 3.81.1.1

References

AW2026:	Anglican Watch website (13 May 2026)
CHU1887:	The Churchman (7 May 1887, p. 517)
DEDUCED:	Deduced from other information
DMA1999:	D. Maitland Armstrong: American Stained Glass Master, Robert O. Jones (1999, p. 95, 114, 213)
DUNC1980:	Tiffany Windows, Alastair Duncan (1980)
EB2026:	Eric Bonetti (Anglican Watch), personal communication (14 May 2026)
FINDAGRAVE:	Findagrave.com, for deducing biographical or genealogical information
INSCRIPTION:	Inscription on item
ORG:	Organization
PHOTO:	Photo of item
RAND2026:	Rand Commercial listing (14 May 2026)
TIFF1886:	Announcement in American Architect and Building News, Tiffany Glass Company (6 Feb 1886)
TIFF1893:	Chicago Exposition booklet, Tiffany Glass & Decorating Company (1893)
TIFF1897:	A List of Windows: And Extracts from Letters & Newspapers, Tiffany Glass & Decorating Company (1897)
TIFF1910:	A Partial List of Tiffany Windows, Tiffany Studios (1910)